Butler Bulldogs vs. Creighton Bluejays Pick & Prediction for December 30 2025
The Butler Bulldogs (10–3, 1–1 Big East) head to Omaha to take on the Creighton Bluejays (8–5, 2–0 Big East) on Tuesday night at 9:00 PM ET at CHI Health Center Omaha, with coverage on FS1. This is one of the better Big East games on the board: Butler brings pace and points, while Creighton is surging and defending at a higher level during this win streak. With this high stakes matchup you are going to have some great results, but you will want to make sure you can check out the best free college basketball picks.
Sign Up for Winners and Whiners News Alerts, Get Free Picks and Discounts
Subscribe Now
Game Snapshot
- Spread: Butler +5.5 (Creighton -5.5)
- Total: 153.5
- Matchup predictor: Creighton favored
Butler: Offence-first team that can turn this into a track meet
Butler has been a scoring machine, averaging 86.4 PPG while shooting a solid 47% and rebounding at a high level (42.3 RPG). They’ve won two straight, including a demolition of NJIT and a gritty 61–58 win over Northwestern. In their last five, they’ve shown multiple paths to wins — they can win fast (101 points), win slow (61 points), or win in pure chaos (113–110 in 2OT vs Providence).
The concern is what happens when Butler’s defence gets stressed. They’re allowing 73.0 PPG, and when they’ve faced higher-end teams, they’ve been more vulnerable (for example, the loss at UConn). Butler’s top scorer listed is Michael Ajayi (16.6 PPG), and for Butler to stay inside the number, they’ll need him and the supporting cast to score efficiently without turning this into a turnover-heavy night against Creighton’s structure.
Creighton: Trending up, defending better, and playing with momentum
Creighton’s overall record is a bit misleading because they’ve clearly found rhythm lately. They’re on a three-game win streak and the quality of those wins jumps off the page: 98–57 at Xavier and 84–63 vs Marquette are the kind of results that signal a team locked in on both ends. Season-long, they average 78.5 PPG and allow 70.4 PPG, which is a more controlled profile than Butler’s, but their recent performances suggest they’re playing faster and cleaner right now.
Their assist numbers (17.5 APG) show a team that moves it and creates good looks, and when Creighton is clicking, they generate the exact kind of shot diet that punishes teams that gamble defensively. Josh Dix (12.2 PPG) is listed as their leading scorer here, and while that number isn’t huge, it also hints at balance — Creighton can beat you with multiple guys rather than one high-usage scorer.
| # | Handicapper | Profit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Tony Karpinski | +2,494.00 |
| 2 |  Joe Duffy | +1,859.00 |
| 3 |  The Insiders Room | +1,788.00 |
| 4 |  Mark Ruelle | +1,428.00 |
| 5 |  Jackie Mack | +1,400.00 |
Key Matchup Angles
1) Tempo battle: Butler wants possessions; Creighton wants control
If Butler gets this into the 75–80 possession range, the total gets very live and Butler’s upset chances improve. If Creighton slows it down, forces longer defensive possessions, and limits transition, Butler can get stuck having to score in the half court repeatedly.
2) Rebounding vs shot quality
Butler’s rebounding edge is real on paper, and that’s how underdogs hang around: extra possessions and second-chance points. Creighton’s counter is cleaner shot quality and better spacing — if they’re hitting shots, Butler’s rebounding advantage doesn’t matter as much because there are fewer misses to clean up.
3) Creighton’s current form vs Butler’s defensive volatility
Creighton’s last three wins weren’t just wins — they were statement wins, and that’s why the line is where it is. Butler can score enough to keep this competitive, but if they have one of those 4–5 minute defensive lapses, Creighton can create separation quickly at home.
Betting Outlook
Spread lean: Creighton -5.5
Creighton’s momentum and defensive profile make sense in this range, especially at home. Butler can absolutely score with them, but Creighton has been the more reliable team recently at turning good play into double-digit margins.
Total lean: Over 153.5 (slight)
Butler games can get wild fast, and they’re comfortable living in the 80s or 90s. The only hesitation is if Creighton successfully dictates pace; still, Butler’s scoring ability keeps the over in play.
Pick and Prediction
Best Bet: Creighton -5.5
I’m backing Creighton because their recent form suggests they’re playing at a higher level than their overall record, and their ability to defend with structure should limit Butler’s easiest points (transition and quick-second chances). Butler will score — they always do — but Creighton’s balance and home-court edge should carry them through.
Projected Final Score: Creighton 82, Butler 74
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
Bet $5 & Get $200
