Dallas Cowboys vs New York Jets Prediction and Picks - October 5th, 2025
Use Code WWWC Sunday afternoon on the NFL gridiron, and we have a Dallas Cowboys vs New York Jets Prediction locked and loaded for you. The Cowboys enter this game off a wild 40-40 tie with the Packers to move to 1-2-1 on the year. The Jets have not had a great start as they have gone 0-4 out the gate and come in off a 27-21 loss at Miami. These teams last met in 2023 and Dallas won that game at home by a score of 30-10. Can the Jets get revenge and also pick up their first win of the year? Read on to see our Cowboys vs Jets prediction.
Want more NFL winners? Check out our award-winning NFL Predictions.
Dallas With A Wild Tie Against The Packers
The Cowboys enter Week 5 at 1–2–1 after a wild 40–40 tie against the Packers, a game that showcased both their offensive firepower and defensive collapse. Dak Prescott was nearly flawless, completing 77.5% of his passes for 319 yards and three touchdowns, while adding a rushing score. George Pickens exploded for 134 yards and two touchdowns in his first game without CeeDee Lamb, who’s sidelined with a high ankle sprain. Javonte Williams continued to anchor the ground game with 85 rushing yards and a touchdown on 20 carries. Dallas racked up 492 total yards and scored on six of its final seven possessions — but couldn’t close the door, allowing Green Bay to match them blow-for-blow in a chaotic second half.
Offensively, Dallas ranks No. 1 in total yards and passing yards, and fifth in scoring at 30.5 points per game. Prescott leads the NFL in completions (121) and passing yards (1,119), operating behind a line that’s held up despite injuries to Tyler Booker and Tyler Guyton. The Cowboys are converting 48.6% of third downs and have committed just two turnovers all season, showing efficiency and balance. Pickens has emerged as a legitimate WR1 threat, and tight end Jake Ferguson continues to be a reliable chain-mover. The run game ranks 12th, with Williams averaging 4.3 yards per carry and providing physicality in short-yardage spots.
Get Free $30 Credit for Premium Picks + Exclusive Discounts
Subscribe Now
Defensively, however, Dallas has been a disaster. They rank dead last in total defense (420.5 YPG), last against the pass (309.3 YPG), and 31st in scoring defense (33.5 PPG). The secondary has allowed a league-high 10 passing touchdowns and has struggled to generate pressure since parting ways with Micah Parsons. The Cowboys have just five sacks through four games and are allowing 7.9 yards per pass attempt — worst in the NFL. Against the Jets, they’ll need to tighten coverage and force Justin Fields into mistakes, especially with Garrett Wilson heating up. If the defense can hold serve, Prescott and the offense have the firepower to take control early.
Jets Still Looking For First Win
The Jets fell to 0–4 after a 27–21 loss to Miami, a game that featured flashes of promise but ultimately ended in frustration. Justin Fields played his best game of the season, throwing for 226 yards and a touchdown while rushing for 81 yards and another score. Breece Hall was explosive, averaging 5.8 yards per carry and adding 30 receiving yards, while Garrett Wilson hauled in six catches for 82 yards and a touchdown. The offense moved the ball well, but penalties and missed opportunities — including a controversial OPI call that wiped out a second Wilson touchdown — kept them from pulling ahead. New York has now lost three games by one score and continues to search for its first win.
Statistically, the Jets rank 21st in total offense, third in rushing, and 29th in passing — a split that reflects their run-heavy identity and Fields’ dual-threat profile. Hall leads the team with 336 rushing yards and is averaging 6.2 yards per carry, while Wilson ranks sixth in the NFL with 311 receiving yards and fourth in targets. Fields has completed 67.1% of his passes with a 5:1 TD-to-INT ratio, but the offense has been plagued by penalties and stalled drives. New York is the most penalized team in the league, averaging 97 yards per game, and has committed seven turnovers — tied for third-most in the NFL. Despite the talent, execution remains inconsistent.
Defensively, the Jets rank 20th in total defense, 25th against the run, and 14th against the pass — a unit that’s been solid but not dominant. They’ve allowed 24.8 points per game and are giving up 5.1 yards per carry, which could be problematic against Javonte Williams and Dallas’ power run game. The secondary is banged up, with nickel corner Michael Carter II in concussion protocol, and the pass rush has been streaky. Linebacker Quincy Williams leads the team with 39 tackles, while Jermaine Johnson has three sacks. Against the Cowboys, the Jets will need to pressure Prescott and disrupt timing routes, especially with Pickens emerging as a deep threat. If they can force a few stops and capitalize on Dallas’ defensive lapses, they’ll have a shot to break through.
Dallas Cowboys vs New York Jets Pick
Cowboys vs Jets Spread Pick
- Jets +2.5 (4 Units)
Jets +2.5 is a strong value play in a matchup where their run game and defensive speed match up well against Dallas’ explosive but unbalanced offense. Justin Fields is coming off his best game of the season, and with Breece Hall averaging over six yards per carry, the Jets have the tools to control tempo and keep Prescott off the field. Garrett Wilson continues to win on the outside, and New York’s ability to generate chunk plays on the ground could expose Dallas’ bottom-ranked run defense. The Cowboys have allowed 5.4 yards per carry and rank 31st in scoring defense — a dangerous combination against a mobile quarterback and a downhill rushing attack.
Situationally, this is a tough spot for Dallas. They’re coming off a draining 40–40 tie and now face a road game against a desperate Jets team that’s lost three one-score games and is due for a breakthrough. The Cowboys’ defense has been shredded through the air and hasn’t forced a turnover in two weeks, while New York’s offense has quietly improved its efficiency and cut down on mistakes. If Fields protects the ball and the Jets avoid drive-killing penalties, they have the edge in physicality and urgency. With the line under a field goal, the value sits with the home dog — especially against a Dallas team that’s shown it can’t close.
Cowboys vs Jets Over/Under Pick
- Over 47.5 (5 Units)
Over 47.5 makes sense in a matchup featuring two explosive quarterbacks, shaky defenses, and playmakers who can flip the field in seconds. Dallas leads the NFL in total offense and passing yards, while the Jets rank third in rushing and have quietly improved their scoring efficiency behind Justin Fields and Breece Hall. The Cowboys’ defense ranks dead last in yards allowed and has given up 33.5 points per game — a glaring weakness that sets up well for Fields’ dual-threat skill set. With Garrett Wilson heating up and George Pickens emerging as a WR1, both teams have the weapons to trade scores and push this total past the number.
Betting on the NFL?
- Be sure to look our our list of the best NFL online sportsbooks
- Grow your bankroll by claiming one of our favorite NFL sportsbook promo codes
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
New Users – Bet $5 Get $200 in Bet Reset Tokens for 5 Days
