Prediction, Preview, and Odds
#911 Boston Red Sox -140 vs.
#912 Toronto Blue Jays 10
Thursday, May 23, 2019 at 12:37pm EDT
Written by Sporty Jordy



#911 Boston
#912 Toronto


This article covers a past game!

View upcoming games.

When and where: May 23, 2019, Rogers Centre, Toronto, Ontario, 12:37 PM ET

The Toronto Blue Jays will try to split even with the Boston Red Sox in the eagerly anticipated series finale on Thursday. After getting blown out on Tuesday, the Red Sox have retaken control of the four-game series with a scintillating win over the Blue Jays on Wednesday. The best the Blue Jays can hope for is avoiding a second-straight loss when the NL East rivals meet for a sixth time this season.

Red Sox’s Martinez resting back injury

The Red Sox were forced to go into Wednesday’s game without batting savant J.D. Martinez, who was kept out of the lineup due to back soreness. Per, Red Sox manager Alex Cora could keep the AL Hank Aaron Award winner out of Thursday’s game as well, citing the artificial surface at Rogers Centre as a concern.

The Red Sox could use a series win after splitting even with the Colorado Rockies and losing to the Houston Astros. Despite climbing back into the AL East race, they have started to slip back into some of the same struggles we saw from them earlier in the season, particularly with the hot-and-cold offensive performances. The Red Sox can drop 15 runs on you one night and then two runs the next night. Rarely has there been any consistency with the offensive effort, and the same goes for their defense. They survived a sensational game against the Blue Jays on Wednesday that needed 13 innings to decide.

Weber, the 28-year-old righty, will be first on the mound for the Red Sox on Thursday. He was called up on May 6 and has since made three appearances as a relief pitcher. He’ll be getting his first start of the season after a string of strong pitching performances against the Houston Astros, Seattle Mariners and Baltimore Orioles. In eight overall appearances on the mound, he has only allowed one earned run—a homer to Astros DH Josh Reddick.

Blue Jays’ offense comes to life

For those thinking the Red Sox would run over the Blue Jays, which was nearly everyone outside of Toronto, things haven’t gone exactly as expected in this series. After getting stomped off their home field in a 12-2 loss, the Blue Jays responded by playing good defense and heaping 10 runs on the Red Sox. Then came Wednesday’s epic 13-inning clash that was ultimately decided by a home run by Red Sox second baseman Michael Chavis.

It has been a struggle for the Blue Jays since sweeping the Oakland Athletics. They have gone on to lose meetings with the Los Angeles Angels, Texas Rangers, Minnesota Twins and Chicago White Sox. They currently sit in fourth place of one of the toughest divisions in baseball without much hope of climbing any higher. They lack the talent on their roster, but most importantly, they have the New York Yankees, Tampa Bay Rays and Red Sox standing in front of them. It was always going to be an uphill battle whether they had the talent or not.

Despite having a feisty defense, they still remain the fifth-worst run-scoring team in baseball, which isn’t surprising considering their offensive limitations overall.

Best Bets for this Game

Full-Game Side Bet

Insiders Status:


The Red Sox had to dig deep in their chest to pull out the heart needed to survive a wild road encounter with the Blue Jays on Wednesday. If not for some truly clutch homers from Chavis and Mookie Betts, there’s a good chance they would have gone home with their second consecutive loss and on the verge of losing another series.

The Blue Jays gave the Red Sox all they could handle in that game, which makes me doubtful of their chances to get back up for Thursday’s game. The Red Sox are four games out from tying the Yankees for wins in the season, and they are hoping to avoid splitting another series. Even without Martinez on the field, the rest of the team rallied and stepped up in an effort to leave Rogers Centre with a victory.

They’ll put forth a similar response in the series finale as well. The Blue Jays had a pair of solid showings on the offensive end, but they’ll revert back to the disappointing team slashing at .220/.368/.288 on the season, which won’t be enough when faced with the Red Sox’s firepower. I like the Red Sox to finish things off and take the series.

Prediction: Boston Red Sox ()

Full-Game Total Pick

Insiders Status:


The over is 5-0 in the last five head-to-head meetings in Toronto between the Red Sox and Blue Jays. While I do expect the Blue Jays to hit an offensive wall, the Red Sox are still one of the best run-scoring teams in the league, averaging 5.27 runs per game. They aren’t going away with Martinez injured, as they showed on Wednesday night, and they’ll be even more motivated to close out the series with a win on Thursday. I like the over betting total in this game.

Prediction: Over

Written By Jordy McElroy , "Sporty Jordy"

Born in Germany and raised in the beautiful state of Tennessee, Jordy McElroy is a storyteller of sports, a sports betting enthusiast and a semi-deep thinker. Being a New England Patriots fan means he's a six-time Super Bowl winner as well, which means you'd have to be a fool to ignore his advice. Prior to joining our team here at Winners & Whiners, Jordy’s work appeared on, FOX Sports, Bleacher Report, USA TODAY and There are no beaches where he comes from -- just rolling hills, green valleys and all the Sun Drop you can drink.