Upcoming Free Picks

An Update on the NFL’s Helmet Rule and Other Infuriating Things

Image licensed from USA Today Sports

After just two weeks worth of preseason football, scores of NFL fans are already riled up. After just of 33 preseason games, NFL referees have called 51 helmet rule penalties. 43 of them have been assessed to defenses while eight have been called on defenses. What is the helmet rule? Well, it’s the latest stupid rule that seems to have been introduced for the sole purpose of watering down a great sport and causing mass confusion. In a nutshell, players are no longer allowed to lower their helmets when they attempt to tackle an opponent.

Any player who lowers his helmet to deliver a hit is given a 15-yard penalty with provisions for ejection, suspension, the assessment of fines, and public shaming on social media for the most severe infractions. Now, this all sounds fairly reasonable on paper, but it’s proving to be anything but in real situations. There has already been a slew of these penalties called against players who appear to be performing perfect form tackles.

Even worse is that the officials on the field don’t appear to be on the same page when it comes to enforcing the rule. Players, coaches, and fans are left scratching their heads in confusion, and this isn’t good for football. It appears this rule was conceived by a group of lawyers hell-bent on protecting their NFL masters from further lawsuits stemming from head injuries. These suits have likely never played the game or even watched it. Nevertheless, they know what’s best. These same Bobby Buzzkills will likely be the same people that get body checking and slap shots banned from hockey and “dunkin’ on people” outlawed in basketball.

Naturally, as with most new rules that are implemented in any professional sport, it can be expected that there will be an adjustment period for all involved. The NFL recently conducted a conference call with the competition committee to discuss the new rule. In the end, the NFL stood by the rule and refused to change a thing although they did clarify that “inadvertent or incidental contact” with a helmet or face mask during the course of play should not result in a penalty. It was also confirmed that helmet violations are not reviewable.

Several fans, coaches, and players have criticized the new rule. Not surprisingly, a very opinionated Richard Sherman weighed in on the subject referring to the rule as “idiotic.” Minnesota Vikings’ coach Mike Zimmer claimed that it will “cost people some jobs.” Raiders defensive coordinator Paul Guenther summed it up nicely when he said that he appreciated the spirit of the rule, but he questioned the practicality of enforcing it. He was quoted as saying “But at some point, it is football.”

Not everyone is unhappy with the new rule and, not surprisingly, NFL’s executive vice president of football operations, Troy Vincent, is one of the few that think this rule is great and the league has done an excellent job in demonstrating what constitutes a violation through a series of videos that were released.

Regardless of what you think about the helmet rule, it looks like it’s here to stay. Football purists might believe that the next logical step for the league to take would be to get rid of the helmets and pads altogether and replace them with sweatpants that have flags hanging out of their waistbands. Let’s just hope that things are sorted out by the time the regular season arrives.

Speaking of things like the helmet rule that has a lot of people confused and causes yet more delays football games, there is also the matter of what exactly constitutes a catch? This question has been raised on many occasions in recent years. Perhaps the most recent example of mass hysteria over the definition came in a game between the Pittsburgh Steelers and the New England Patriots last year.

To refresh your memory, Pittsburgh’s tight end Jesse James appeared to catch a pass from Ben Roethlisberger and score a go-ahead touchdown in the dying seconds of an important game which would have altered the universe in unimaginable ways. The rules seem pretty clear but they still seem to have a certain degree of ambiguity around them. Simply put, a player that goes to the ground while making a catch has to have control of the ball before he hits the ground. In the Jesse James case, the ball came loose as he crossed the goal line and he was tackled before he could regain control of the ball. That is why it was not ruled a catch.

To be precise, Rule 8, Section 1, Article 3, Item 1 says that "A player is considered to be going to the ground if he does not remain upright long enough to demonstrate that he is clearly a runner. (As was the case with James) If a player goes to the ground in the act of catching a pass (with or without contact by an opponent), he must maintain control of the ball until after his initial contact with the ground, whether in the field of play or the end zone. (Which James did not) If he loses control of the ball, and the ball touches the ground before he regains control, the pass is incomplete." That should clear things up.

It seems so easy to those of us sitting in our easy chairs who are treated to slow-motion instant replays from a variety of angles immediately following any given play but it isn’t quite the same on the field. Things happen in the blink of an eye and even the most experienced NFL referees need to pause and take a second and even third look. That is why these plays are reviewable. Of course, that doesn’t mean that officials will always get it right.

One of the other rules that have come under fire recently is the one that goes something like “if you fumble it through the end zone and it goes out of bounds then it’s a touchback”. What makes this rule so, as Richard Sherman might say, idiotic is that the defending team didn’t gain possession so, by definition, it should not be a turnover. This rule could be changed so easily but, alas, it is another one of those frustrating rules that the NFL brass has no desire to change. It’s no wonder that Valium sales spike on Sundays!

Finally, another rule that you might not be aware of is one that penalizes any player who makes contact with the head or neck of a long snapper. This one has actually been in the books for a few years but the NFL is going to be enforcing the rule this year with extra diligence. Long snappers have always been quite vulnerable and the NFL wants to do all they can to protect them. Many will argue that this rule doesn’t go far enough but at least it doesn’t go too far like that moronic helmet rule. Don’t get me started on that one again!!

The Admiral

You want someone to show you how to make some money, then talk to me, I am your man. Folks, I have been doing this since....forever, so yeah, I know a thing or two on how to beat the spread and get your pockets loaded with the totals. Basketball, Soccer, Football, Hockey, you name it, and I will find the best pick for you.

Login

Forgot Password?
Forgot your password? Enter your email and we'll send you a reset token:

Return to login
Enter the token from your email and a new password. Don't forget to check your spam folder if you didn't get the email.

Upcoming Free Picks

Bank the Bet Podcast
Thursday, Jan 17
NBA
#541 New York Knicks 228
#542 Washington Wizards -6.5
3:05pm
View Pick
#543 Philadelphia 76ers 224.5
#544 Indiana Pacers -3
7:05pm
View Pick
#545 Sacramento Kings 230
#546 Charlotte Hornets -3
7:05pm
View Pick
#547 Phoenix Suns
#548 Toronto Raptors
7:35pm
View Pick
#549 Chicago Bulls 212
#550 Denver Nuggets -12
9:05pm
View Pick
#551 Los Angeles Lakers 226
#552 Oklahoma City Thunder -10
9:35pm
View Pick
NCAAB
#601 FAU 151
#602 Marshall -9
7:00pm
View Pick
#603 Charleston 139.5
#604 Northeastern -3.5
7:00pm
View Pick
#605 Georgia Southern -2
#606 Troy 161
7:00pm
View Pick
#607 UNCW 152
#608 Hofstra -12.5
7:00pm
View Pick
#609 James Madison 134
#610 Delaware -4
7:00pm
View Pick
#611 Towson 146
#612 Drexel -5.5
7:00pm
View Pick
#613 Wright State -5.5
#614 Youngstown State 141.5
7:00pm
View Pick
#615 Southern Miss -4.5
#616 Charlotte 122.5
7:00pm
View Pick
#617 Louisiana Tech 129
#618 ODU -6.5
7:00pm
View Pick
#619 Northern Kentucky -9
#620 Cleveland State 142
7:00pm
View Pick
#621 UTSA -3.5
#622 Middle Tennessee State 137.5
7:30pm
View Pick
#637 Georgia State -5.5
#638 South Alabama 141
8:00pm
View Pick
#635 UTEP 132
#636 UAB -8
8:00pm
View Pick
#633 Michigan State -1
#634 Nebraska 144
8:00pm
View Pick
#631 Illinois - Chicago -3
#632 Wisconsin-Milwaukee 142.5
8:00pm
View Pick
#629 IUPUI 163
#630 Wisconsin-Green Bay -4
8:00pm
View Pick
#627 FIU 163.5
#628 Western Kentucky -13
8:00pm
View Pick
#625 Arkansas - Little Rock 140
#626 Texas State -11.5
8:00pm
View Pick
#623 Arkansas State 139.5
#624 UT Arlington -4.5
8:00pm
View Pick
#639 Loyola Marymount
#640 Gonzaga
9:00pm
View Pick
#641 Stanford 138
#642 Washington -10
9:00pm
View Pick
#643 Oregon 130
#644 Arizona -4.5
9:00pm
View Pick
#645 San Francisco -6.5
#646 Pacific 138
9:00pm
View Pick
#647 Hawaii 148
#648 Cal State Northridge -2
10:00pm
View Pick
#649 California
#650 Washington State
10:00pm
View Pick
#651 Oregon State 141
#652 Arizona State -5.5
10:00pm
View Pick
#653 San Diego -10
#654 Portland 134
10:00pm
View Pick
#657 UCSB -3
#658 UC Davis 131.5
10:00pm
View Pick
#659 Santa Clara
#660 St Marys
11:00pm
View Pick
#661 BYU -2.5
#662 Pepperdine 163
11:00pm
View Pick
NHL
#31 New Jersey 6
#32 N.Y. Islanders -150
7:05pm
View Pick
#33 St. Louis 5.5
#34 Boston -175
7:05pm
View Pick
#41 Anaheim 5.5
#42 Minnesota -180
8:05pm
View Pick
#43 Los Angeles 5.5
#44 Dallas -175
8:35pm
View Pick
Saturday, Jan 19
NCAAB
#629 James Madison
#630 Drexel
2:00pm
View Pick
Sunday, Jan 20
NFL
#311 Los Angeles Rams 56.5
#312 New Orleans Saints -3.5
3:05pm
View Pick
#313 New England Patriots 58
#314 Kansas City Chiefs -3
6:40pm
View Pick